Jean Clments Holmes is so French, he is almost unbearably French. Hagmans Holmes is lighthearted and played for laughs, with verve and a dash of pip pip cheerio Englishness, much too much to make it a serious contender on this list. That rat is the GOAT. 20. HOW DID THIS NEVER HAPPEN? What he IS is a Holmes who is sharp, quick on the uptake, and always ready to spring into action. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Andrew Gower, Murdoch Mysteries, A Study in Scarlet (2013). Im stressing the bathroom thing because its just so nutty. (Fun fact, this TV movie gave Holmes a lady sidekick named Dr. Joan Watson DECADES before Elementary.) Basil Rathbone, The Hound of the Baskervilles (1939), etc. Honestly, I could listen to it all day. Although I honestly dont think looking back with all the new detective style games out now if I would recommend buying more than one or two boxes. It's a good place to start. 50. Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective: The Baker Street Irregulars A Game by Van Ryder Games 1-8 Players 90 Minutes of Gameplay Games for Family Game Night Teens & Adults Ages 14+ - English Brand: Van Ryder Games 8 ratings $2999 FREE Returns Available at a lower price from other sellers that may not offer free Prime 48. We havent played a lot of the Sherlock Holmes boxes, but Id also add Mythos Tales to the mix, even though its not Holmes. But she is also glamorous! WebSherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases (1982) The game is afoot as you and your irregular friends search Victorian London for clues 20K Charlton Heston. 78. He doesnt seem like a genius, but ha molto sale in zucca, an expression which means he has a lot of sense. And literally translates to he has a lot of salt in his gourd., 45. 83. He was committed to creating as authentic a portrayal of the character as possible. Looking for a group of 5-6 as this is my first time running a pbp game. Nicholas Rowe, Young Sherlock Holmes (1985). Interestingly, Arthur Conan Doyles estate sued the film for making Holmes appear too sensitive, which is funny, because Ive seen calabash pipes with greater depth. Heel. Robert Webb, Holmes and Watson, That Mitchell and Webb Look (2010). The group leader needs post the ref only once per day, all are free to chat about the case/clues as much as they want. Gregory House is not on this list. WebA good new addition to the Consulting Detective series on Sherlock Holmes, this book consists of 4 cases - which range from good to great: 1 - The Scotland Yard Murder: 67. Id like this performance, or this movie, more if it bothered to interrogate this element which is present in the original Holmes stories (as well as suffuses all of nineteenth and turn-of-the-century literature), rather than just use it for entertainment. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective Interactive DVD Mysteries Like New at the best online prices at eBay! Yes, I know its a performance that lots of people like, but I find a tad insufferable, mostly because Downeys British accent is so grandiloquent, especially when he whispers or thinks-in-voiceover, which happens a lot. George C. Scott, They Might Be Giants (1971). Its star, Yko Takeuchi, is riveting as Sherlock, an elegant, if aloof and snide, young woman who uses her brilliant observational powers to solve crimes, mostly for her own amusement. Or, he didnt not benefit from the rise of Nazis, lets put it that way. Williamsons Holmes gets points for sounding very smart while speaking very quickly, and whipping out his magnifying glass and breathing on it like hes blowing smoke off the muzzle of a pistol. Guy Henry, Young Sherlock: The Mystery of the Manor House (1982). This always feels very authentic to me. It features a combination of decent special effects and terrible fight choreography. The two took advantage of the ventilation system and their scientific knowledge to take down a man who was arguably no saint to those around him. In Carlton House at least there is definitely a reference to Thames scenarios and newspapers. This isnt the first old Holmes take Ive seen, but its the one that kicks me in the tear ducts the hardest. Two former gangsters have been killed in Half Moon Street during the celebrations of Queen Victoria's Jubilee. He went off to hunt down Lord Marsh and his buddies in an act of vengeance, and it is up to Holmes to let him continue with his vigilante justice or put a stop to it. The Awakened sees Holmes and Watson alerted to a possible kidnapping ring and a string of gory murders. Please note that were ranking Sherlock Holmes portrayals (characters who are literally supposed to be Sherlock Holmes), not portrayals of characters who are based on or inspired by Sherlock Holmes. 24. Maybe their performances arent really takes on Holmes, since they are really just playing two actors who are competitive with another and wind up building tension as they switch roles from Holmes to Watson, but whatever, its great. He might be a flash more arrogant than Doyles Holmes, but hes never overweening; hell even occasionally burst out laughing or grin with excitement. I think he meant the different versions, like Thames murders vs jack the ripper. Known Dr. Watson impersonator Patrkck Macnee (previously, he played the Good Doctor alongside both Roger Moore and Christopher Lees Holmeses) takes a turn as The Man Himself in this crawling Canadian adaptation, as an older, weary, high, and slightly suicidal Holmes. Quality of acting? The game sends you away from the familiar streets of London to the depths of a Swiss asylum, and eventually the crocodile-infested swamps of New Orleans. If you are not into books, try the Timmy Failure Island on Poptropica, the super-fun games website made by Diary of a Wimpy Kid author, Jeff Kinney. Typically we play in large-ish groups. 22. But Im especially impressed with how totally relaxed he is theres nothing frenetic, or even too excitable there. Let the record show that hes much less of an asshole than DArcys older version. In this Danish silent film, he mostly stands around in a double-breasted suit and points at things, but hey, it seems to work! Even, to deduce. (However, I DO have a question about how old this Holmes is supposed to be? Rupert Everett, Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Silk Stocking (2004). A man named Albeit - who was presumed dead - was planning to kill all his colleagues who were with him during a Mayan expedition. The Germans made a lot of Sherlock Holmes movies in 1937, and a bunch of them involve guys with stereotypically English names who turn out to be Sherlock Holmes in disguise. They had betrayed him and left him to die, causing the seed of vengeance to take root within him. He is more soft-spoken and muttery than his scowl would suggest, which is rather intriguing. No question. But Mitchell steals the show as Holmes in another sketch anyway, which is just below. This version has been cleaned up and is largely free of the errors and issues that affected previous iterations. I have the data. Hes better at it now, even though he probably has a concussion, which is not how concussions work. Welcome to the r/TimmyFailure subreddit! You bet. In my mind, this is the best parody of Sherlock Holmes out there not only does it make fun of the novels and adaptation legacies of Holmes and Watson in a very charming way, but it adds in entirely new elements that are flat-out hysterical, such as Holmes and Watson successfully hailing a horse-driven hansom cab in the middle of 1970s London. Sherlock Holmes and the Deadly Necklace is pretty boring, and even Christopher Lee, who presents an urbane and erudite Holmes, cant really save it. Sit. One can only imagine how good he would have been on stage, solving a puzzle whose answer didnt live in a junior-high-school earth science textbook. Ronald Howard, Sherlock Holmes (1954-1955). Bruno Gttner, Der Hund von Baskerville (1937). Gary Piquer, Holmes & Watson: Madrid Days (2012). He also says great things like: You are the stormy petrel of crime, Watson. A faultless performance. Sherlock Holmes did indeed. Sher standed for Sure and Lock because he solved cases so if you put it together he was sure to solve and unlock the case. And Holmes because he is very comforting as a home is to anyone. What cases does Sherlock Holmes solve? Sherlock preferred interesting cases, ones where it wouldn't be so easy to solve. 4. Not the one where Sherlock is sitting on a chair, the new brown box. The idea that Holmes and Watson might be looking to best one another isnt played with enough. The case is quite complex since all three suspects have a strong motive for killing Fabio. Sherlock Holmes 's thrilling tales as a consulting detective in Victorian-era London have made him a veritable staple in the mystery and crime genre. The #1 Reddit source for news, information, and discussion about modern board games and board game culture. Tom Baker, The Hound of the Baskervilles (1982). Thames. The latter took out his rage on the sex workers, blaming them for causing his son to be born with syphilis, and physically disfiguring his victims the way his son had been. Dinsdales Holmes is first seen, Hamlet-style, complaining to the human skull in his outstretched hand about how bored he is. I own all 4 boxes and have probably played 25 of them. Carlyle Blackwell is a stony but captivating Holmes in this gorgeous silent film (the last silent Sherlock Holmes film ever made). I hope that one day, Richard Roxburgh, the consummate and transformative actor, and Alan Tudyk, another consummate and transformative actor, will play brothers in a film, because they look almost exactly the same, but anyway, Roxburgh (whom you probably know best as the Duke from Moulin Rouge) is a very, very solid Holmes in this very, very solid BBC adaptation that, frankly, I like. Tall, gaunt, hawkish, slightly sardonic It really makes you wish he HAD played Holmes on screen, for real. Talent recognizing genius, just like Holmes told us it does. Holmes managed to prove his innocence once he unmasked Professor Moriarty as the Bishop's killer. (Literally, his voice is very breathy.) His accent is not amazing, but his intonation is good, if that makes sense. 76. De Almeida offers an incongruously dignified detective at the start, who has to retrograde in many ways over the course of the film. Is Carleton House no fun at all? And of course, yes, the quality of the performance itself matters. Dean Fujioka, a singer-songwriter as well as an actor, definitely gives us a very cool, bad-boy Holmes: arrogant, brilliant, and solving crimes possibly as an alternative to committing them. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/deadvillainsociety/nick-macari-presents-the-man-who-died-twice-graphic-novel?ref=dbwodu. Its nice to see a Holmes who clearly loves being the center of attention, so much. And his portrayal sets the precedent for more swashbuckling liberties in adaptations to come. 66. He gets high, has sex, eats a lot, and frequently has to run to the bathroom. Don't start with this. This version has been cleaned up and is largely Carlton House & Queens Park is the black sheep of the current releases and Is it just me or is Baker Street Irregulars a little hard to find at the moment? His Holmes wants to be a professional violinist, but he zero talent whatsoever in this department. John Neville, A Study in Terror (1965). Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson. A dash defensive instead of totally probing. Reece Dinsdale, Science Fiction: Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Missing Link (1992). Theres a real WHAT A PIECE OF WORK IS MAN vibe about him which makes his performance feel quite Classical. Igor Khristenko, Sherlock Holmes (2009). Because it fits. 32. The TurboGrafx-16 video game console was joint-developed by Hudson Soft and NEC, released in Japan on October 30, 1987, and in the United States on August 19, 1989. My apologies to the Man of Steel, but hes at the very bottom of our list. Join our community! Its truly marvelous to behold (though more marvelous is how he never once turns around to flick Nigel Bruces idiot Watson on the head). Nous, Yahoo, faisons partie de la famille de marques Yahoo. Despite the fact that this movie, about how some occult magic allows Arthur Conan Doyle to meet his creation Sherlock Holmes, is wacko, Richard E. Grant is a superb Holmes. His eyes almost glow with ideas. Relatedly, this version also features what I believe is the canons most slappable Watson. Stephens conveys a lighthearted bemusement alongside a kind of secret weariness, in a complex and moving performance that keeps the film from swerving into silliness, particularly when the Loch Ness monster arrives. Here we will teach, learn, and share will the goal of improving everyone's skills and education. WebFind many great new & used options and get the best deals for Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective SEE DESCRIPTION at the best online prices at eBay! (Because Michael Caine is in every crimey genre movie ever made.) 10. I hate competition. Im not kidding. If you follow all the clues and make the right deductions, then you'll come to the right conclusion: Martyn Hamish and Miss White worked together to kill Dunne. His clever, velvety voice carries the whole production. Woodwards middle-aged Holmes is not afraid to shout and scold; his is an imperious energy. My grandfather, who was from New York City and never wore tweed, had a magnifying glass that I frequently asked to play with, and it always was impressive when he procured it. Did you ever find it anywhere? Charlton Heston, The Crucifer of Blood (1991). Stewart Granger, The Hound of the Baskervilles (1972), I wish the most interesting thing about this movie were Stewart Grangers bushy-browed Sherlock Holmes, but that honor definitely goes to Mr. William Shatner, who is unexplainably in this film as Stapleton. The Chileans won a mining contract which the Mexicans desperately wanted. His young Holmes is game and brave brilliant and confident but NOT nerdy (thats reserved for Watson), but with a bouncy youthfulness that fits this adventure. But Plummer is incredible, bringing a fantastically new and memorable energy to the role. Like all the other silent films on this list, the necessary pantomime and histrionics of silent film acting styles makes the film hard to evaluate alongside talkies (which not only feature speech, but also by nature involve subtler physical performance styles). Edward Woodward, Hands of a Murderer (1990). And he also cant solve the current case well! Khristenkos Sherlock is especially noteworthy for this impassioned solo and also for making me feel more flabbergasted than at any other point in my life. The murder victim was Fabio, a former slave-turned-sex worker. Brent Spiner, Elementary, Dear Data, Star Trek: The Next Generation (1988). You, too, will not be able to get this song out of your head, and you, like I, will despise me for introducing it to you. The second case in Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments begins when a train Holmes and Watson were waiting for mysteriously disappears before their very eyes. Make your own games and play how YOU want! I keep thinking this is David Hyde Pierce. This film is no different; the German (and eventually kind of Nazi) movie star Hans Albers plays Morris Flynn, a guy who turns out to really be Holmes. Holmes & Watson, which is such a vacuous movie, features gung-ho performances by Will Ferrell and John C. Reilly as Holmes and Watson (respectively). Knocked a few points because the whole thing makes him seem a little postal. Jeremy Brett, The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (1984-1985), etc. In this Spanish-language film made by Academy Award winner Jos Luis Garci, Holmes and Watson wind up in Spain, investigating a Jack the Ripper copycat. dvelopper et amliorer nos produits et services. Gazzolos Holmes is very logical. The film on the whole is one of my favorite Holmes takes because it deals with Watsons editorial input, stressing how Watson co-creates a Holmsian image for the public (and, fun fact, it is also the favorite Holmes film of Sherlock-co-creator Mark Gatiss, who has acknowledged that the series owes an enormous debt to the film, which it REALLY does, good lord). In fact, this was the hardest list I have ever had to put together. Okay, here goes I think Robert Downey Jr.s Sherlock Holmes is a sack of hot air. David Mitchells senile Holmes is kind of, maybe, possibly played for laughs, but this too is in service of the tragic thesis undergirding it: the sad irony of the deterioration of the greatest mind of the age. Its also very difficult to appropriately rank William Gillette, the most impactful of the early actors who played Sherlock Holmes onscreen, because he did so in a silent-film adaptation of his popular turn-of-the-century Sherlock Holmes play. Pour en savoir plus sur la faon dont nous utilisons vos donnes personnelles, veuillez consulter notre politique relative la vie prive et notre politique en matire de cookies. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. It turns out Moriarty sent his goons to murder the Bishop in order to obtain an important document as well as to silence him. This Turing Test of a film is really focused on Holmess personal life (if hes a machine or a man with feelings), and its waggish notes are underpinned with a deep melancholy. I feel like if I saw him at a friends house for dinner, hed tell me an anecdote from his career as a bookbinder or watchmaker and warn me about walking home alone at night and tell me its bad luck to whistle indoors. Now that you know our methods, Watson, let us present EW's ranking of 10 of the best Sherlock Holmes actors of all time. I would happily settle in for hours to listen to him read my Adobe Licensing Agreement (SOMEONE has to, or Im going to keep making images for this site in MS Paint). Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Nando Gazzolo, Lultimo dei Baskerville (1968), etc. The 100 Best, Worst, and Strangest Sherlock Holmes Portrayals of All-Time, Ranked. This very lovely, short-lived Japanese cartoon series (whose first six episodes were directed by Hayao Miyazaki, incredibly) adapts the cast of Sherlock Holmes as animals. Jos Baviera, Arsenio Lupin vs Sherlock Holmes (1947). Pete Holmes is very funny as a Cumberbatch-esque Holmes who cant actually deduce anything correctly, but who still confidently makes wild assertions. How about we move forward with Matt Berry? 42. 38. Millers Holmes is healing, and his performance calibrates the strains and pains of making emotional connections. 8. But its a fascinating concept Sherlock Holmess positioned as a romantic Socrates of sorts, sitting on the ground, watching everybody, figuring them out. Creativeness of the interpretations? Charlene is also an aspiring fantasy writer and is currently working to finish her first book. Ilya Oleynikovs Sherlock Holmes, from a sketch in this Russian comedy show, answers the popular and essential question, what would it look like if you cast Peter Falk to play Sherlock Holmes, but if Peter Falk were being played by Walter Matthau. ), 72. Its 44. Ian Sinclair provides a gravelly, monotonous English-Language VO to a Holmes with a glower and a beanie in this TV-MA anime series which pits a modern Holmes against a modern Jack the Ripper. Raymond Massey, The Speckled Band, (1931). This is a combination of 4 new cases and 6 older ones. Deerstalkers off to you, gentlemen. If a character does not have the same name as Holmes (such as Basil of Baker Street) it is because virtually everything else about him is the exact same. Ilya Oleynikov, The Dancing Men, Town Lives of Outstanding People (1995). 18. Robert Stephens, The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes (1970). Gilbert M. Anderson, The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes; or, Held for Ransom (1905). 94. This modern Japanese adaptation of Sherlock Holmes turns its Sherlock (Shishio Homare) into an emo genius in a long trench coat who, his psychologist friend notes, smiles whenever he encounters something evil. WebZojoi teamed up with famed board game company Sleuth Times to reproduce the award-winning Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective video mysteries for Windows and Mac. What Holmes did not expect was for the murders to lead to something bigger. Unlike Young Sherlock Holmes, which transplants the dynamic from the stories onto preteen avatars, this series is supposed to be an origin story for Young Holmes, and I have to say its pretty unappealing. Im only including one Sherlock performance per actor, even if that actor played Sherlock a few times in different productions, so, yes David Mitchell also played Holmes in the above sketch. 5. There are several free cases available: An Irregular Meeting and The Vanishing from Hyde Park are short demo cases, and The Mystified Murderess from The Thames Murders is available in full (that link contains the second demo case too). 28. Jos Baviera wins the award for the Sherlock Holmes actor who looks the most like Orson Welles and the least like Sherlock Holmes. Like a beagle, kind of. There are so many things at work here that need to be teased out in a longer evaluation, especially Vanderpors playing a Sherlock Holmes who speaks Chinese but also literally doesnt! I swear, Michael Caine pops up on every single list I make. This adaptation really stresses his bond with Watson, and prominently showcases his soliciting of Watsons help. Nevertheless, Hands of a Murderer is notable for its showcasing the Baker Street Irregulars, Holmess network of street urchins who aid him in surveillance, and Holmes is kind to them and pays them well, which reveals a nice dimension of his character, even if another aforementioned dimension stresses is his colonialism-informed racism. Hes really quite boring and ordinary, even though hes supposed to be a mastermind. Now, my issues with his portrayal are intertwined with my issues with the script, which is based on William Gillettes Sherlock Holmes play (youll read about that down below). John Barrymore, Sherlock Holmes (1922). Please allow me to present the most complicated Sherlock Holmes performance on this list! ), gives a weirdly uninteresting performance of a straight-man Sherlock Holmes who doesnt wear clothes under the silk robe he sits around in. Makes you wonder if his Sherlock Holmes has a backstory in which he served as the unsmiling headmaster of a countryside all-boys school. Si vous souhaitez personnaliser vos choix, cliquez sur Grer les paramtres de confidentialit. Also, CrimeReads editor Molly Odintz adores this movie. 27. Piquers Holmes is a salt-and-peppery dilettante mostly super worried about his girlfriend Irene Adler not being into him. London is a city full of crime and intrigue, and Mr. Holmes does not have time to pursue every single case. Tabletop Simulator is the only simulator where you can let your aggression out by flipping the table! This is definitely the worlds best take on an idiot-Holmes-who-does-not-know-hes-an-idiot. (The other noteworthy thing about this film is that it features an appearance from Anna May Wong, the first Chinese-American movie star. There have been so many wonderful theatrical portrayals of our Man from Baker Street, but unfortunately, we can include almost none of them! When we first see John Barrymore as Sherlock Holmes in this contemporary-set adaptation, he is sitting on the ground outdoors in a pastoral cobblestone alleyway, leaning up against a wall, smoking copiously and meditatively.